What’s Tax Got to Do With It?

Apparently everything!

With the continued public rantings about tax avoidance and the like, the FTSE4Good independent committee, which complies the list by measuring the performance of companies that meet globally recognised corporate responsibility standards, and in turn facilitates investment in those companies, has been asked to consider excluding companies engaged in overly aggressive tax reduction policies from this ethical index.

Problem Is..

…with tax avoidance so commonplace  among multinationals some fear that if this was used as a means of ‘culling’ the index and ranking stocks according to the ‘ethics’ of their tax practices, not only would there be no ‘ethical’  index, there would be no stock  left in which to invest!

Still, Some Are Trying…

…to come up with an ‘ethical’ ranking based on considerations of tax.

For example:

  • Jacky Prudhomme and Helena Vines-Fiesta, co-heads of Environmental, Social & Governance research at BNP Paribas Investment Partners, are said to be working on a system for screening out companies with inappropriate tax practices. This Paris-based asset manager had 513 billion euros in assets under management as of March 2012.
  • Michael Lewis, tax policy adviser with ActionAid – which has campaigned against multinationals shifting profits beyond the reach of tax authorities in developing countries – believes their work on a guide for investors outlining how they can pressure companies on tax could help funds develop a framework that could determine ‘ethical’ tax criteria.
  • Charles Hennan, investment director at British fund management firm Kennox points to a regime that could screen companies based on his view that  if a firm is paying a low rate of tax, chances are, it’s unsustainable.
  • In a similar vein some investors consider how far increases in net profit are due to operational improvements, which can be maintained, or to tax management. which , in theory, can be reversed by a robust tax audit.


Seems to me….

…that if the FSTE4Good wants to factor matters of ‘tax’ or more precisely the avoidance of it , in its list of criteria to rank socially responsible stock it must not ask whether the practice of tax avoidance by a company itself  is ‘unethical’ but rather how much does the company’s practice of tax management affect its bottom line?

If profits are driven principally by creative, but perfectly legal, book-keeping, rather than good operational management and the strength of the company’s brand, product or service then this could be legitimate grounds for an ‘ethical’ judgement.


4 thoughts on “What’s Tax Got to Do With It?

    1. Hello! Thanks for commenting on my blog. I’ve been blogging for almost two years. I’m happy to hear that you like the look it took me a little while to get the hang of it but so far so good.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s