Why the G8 Needs Tax Havens.

g8

Never mind the public grandstanding about tax havens, in the lead up to next week’s G8 Summit in Northern Ireland. To stay rich, not only do the world’s eight wealthiest countries want tax havens, they need them.

By tax haven I do not mean a secrecy jurisdiction. Instead I am referring to a transparent, low or zero tax jurisdiction whose ‘right standing’ has been confirmed by the OECD in their updated ‘whitelist’ of countries in substantial compliance with international disciplines on transparency and the exchange of confidential taxpayer information. In fact, the only jurisdiction not on this list is characterised as committed to these rules but yet to implement them.

After the Vatican, this country, covering just 21 square miles (8.1sq.mi), is the world’s second least populated country, with 9,378 residents. As it continues to grapple with one of the highest rates of diabetes in the world, you can imagine that diverting national resources to fix a problem, not of their doing, may not be high on Nauru’s political agenda.

nauru 

Not all tax havens are created equal, but to survive they must all remain focussed on providing value for money. Moreover, whatever their historical antecedents, population size, and whether are not they are located onshore or offshore; the members of the G8 need them.

Why?  The simple reason is competition.

Although the anti-tax haven lobby spends millions trying to convince us that the single biggest cause of poverty is the tax saving shenanigans of immoral multinational corporations (MNCs); and that their primary motivation in using lawful tax avoidance measures is to take ‘food out of the mouths’ of babes’, the reason why poverty persists is just not that simple.

It is easy to preach that the only thing corporate shareholders and executives have in mind is the exploitation of local communities, reminiscent of the ‘slash and burn’ agricultural practices of the past. Indeed, if you allow the recurrent news headlines of corporate malfeasance, especially those involved in the extractive industries, to cloud your perspective, then you are apt to dismiss not as well publicized millions spent on charitable causes by these, and other MNCs.

Is this widespread corporate philanthropy driven by guilt?  I don’t expect so.

Just as certain types of business practices are now accepted as unsustainable, so too is a certain kind of corporate ethos. Conglomerates now know that ultimately, the continued viability of their business model is not only dependent on customer retention and brand loyalty. What is also important is the support of the communities in which they operate and at whose behest they are able to source their raw materials.

It just makes good business sense.

The fact is, poverty is a two-sided equation. One half of the equation may be illustrated by the offering of a bribe, but that equation is only ‘balanced’ when the bribe is accepted. Corrupt public officials in the poorest countries, who watch their own people starve, while they enjoy many times a multiple of what they could ever need during their earthly existence, often lies at the heart of the poverty pandemic. This is why the Global Corruption Index is key to tackling poverty which measures the culpability of the parties, on both sides of the poverty ‘equation’, so that real solutions can be found and applied.

If we can step away from the very emotive but sound-bite worthy idea that tax havens cause poverty  because they enable bribery and corruption,  then maybe we can get to the real reason why MNCs employ so much time and effort in tax mitigation, and the truth about why poverty exists.

starbucks

One very good reason why tax havens are used by MNCs to structure and manage their global affairs is because of the high rates of tax, principally, but not limited to, corporate income tax, in their home state, and the states where they sell their goods and services. As Apple, Google and others have explained, if the tax burden in the country where your company is set up is just shy of 40%, and the applicable taxes in the place where your goods and services are sold are also in that percentile, it makes good business sense to find a way to reduce the tax burden to manageable portions; in support of the growth of the business; and more importantly, because the generation of profits using legal means, is the company’s fiduciary obligation its shareholders.

Tax avoidance, unless it is proscribed because it is ‘aggressive’, is not unlawful. This is why in the absence of illegality; countries who complain about not getting their “fair share of taxes” invariably have to beseech companies to voluntarily pay more. This itself is another example of charitable giving by MNCs, in this case, to a state’s revenue authourity.

Why are high taxes a problem?

Competition.

competition

MNCs are in competition for shareholders, customers and the inputs needed to create the goods and services they sell. The easiest way to improve your financial position as a company, just like the case of an individual, is to reduce your taxes. That the MNCs spend large sums of money to optimise tax savings, is testimony to the importance of the exercise and the considerable dividends it can yield.

Again, it all makes good business sense.

Where do most of the world’s biggest multinationals call ‘home’?  The countries of the G8.  Afterall, you don’t get to be a member of the G8 without  having MNCs; that’s why these countries are rich.

It’s in the interest of the G8 countries to support their MNCs and their use of tax havens because of the many back linkages to their own economies, created by solvent companies; such as jobs, foreign currency and other revenue raising measures that can be applied to the activities of the MNCs. Equally important is their listing and cross-listing on the stock markets of the G8, which is itself another driver and indicator of national wealth.

If the G8 don’t want tax havens, then by eliminating the chief reasons why companies go ‘offshore’ they could quite easily undermine the business model of these jurisdictions. The failure of the G8 to modernise their tax laws, which continue to distort global financial markets and create the market for tax havens in the first place, means that the G8 needs low and zero tax jurisdictions; but only those that can be made acceptable to the public by demonstrating transparency and a willingness to share confidential information about their clients.

mncs

If the G8 really wants to help the poor and starving, they can do so much more if they take the focus off the size of their tax base and instead deal with the issue of hunger head on. This will not be achieved by vilifying MNCs who, the developed, developing and under-developed states need. In the end, the reason why, despite the protracted recession, the G8 countries are still the wealthiest in the world, is because of the success of their MNCs, and their use of tax havens – everybody’s not so dirty, not so secret, secret.

 

Advertisements

72 thoughts on “Why the G8 Needs Tax Havens.

  1. s proudest moment despite his record being broken in 2003 by a climber called Yuichiro Miura, who was seventy years old when he made it to the summit. The backpack also comes with mesh pockets, which is super nice because you can see everything and it also saves you so much time not digging around in the bag trying to find an assignment or whatever else you happen to be looking for. Visit a shop that specializes in camping gear, they can give you the perfect advice when it comes to backpacks.

    Like

  2. Thanks on your marvelous posting! I genuinely enjoyed reading it, you could be a great author. I will make sure to bookmark your blog and will eventually come back in the future. I want to encourage you to definitely continue your great posts, have a nice holiday weekend!

    Like

  3. The fingerprint reader eliminates the need for users to remember multiple passwords (now that’s a nice feature. Notebook battery life is a big concern among users due to the high costs of battery replacement. On the whole you will be a winner if you get to use this notebook.

    Like

  4. Do you mind if I quote a few of your posts as long as I provide credit and sources back to your webpage? My blog is in the very same area of interest as yours and my users would really benefit from some of the information you present here. Please let me know if this okay with you. Thank you!

    Like

  5. I know this if off topic but I’m looking into starting my own blog and was curious what all is required to get setup? I’m assuming having a blog like yours would cost a pretty penny? I’m not very internet savvy so I’m not 100% positive. Any tips or advice would be greatly appreciated. Many thanks

    Like

  6. These dogs have a fierce loyalty to their owners and his family, and will defend them even to the death. Surrounded by valleys and greenery with a colonial architectural scene in the heart of the city, Cordoba is a major tourist destination for Latin Americans and globe trotters around the world. Tawny Port is a lighter color that Ruby Port with categories of ten, twenty, thirty, and over forty years.

    Like

  7. Panda four.1 has officially hit the Google search results Earlier this week, we started a slow rollout of an enhanced Panda algorithm, and we anticipate to have everything carried out sometime next week.

    Like

  8. Howdy just stumbled upon your blog from Google after I typed in, “Why the G8 Needs Tax Havens. ” or perhaps something similar (can’t quite remember exactly). Anyhow, I’m delighted I found it simply because your content is exactly what I’m searching for (writing a college paper) and I hope you don’t mind if I gather some material from here and I will of course credit you as the reference. Thanks.

    Like

  9. The clinic portion, run by Revolution Academy coaches, will feature Revs players as celebrity coaches and will be followed by a Q&A and autograph session. After he got a divorce, he left town and started a new life, finally meeting a really nice girl who he proposed to. For large areas, try planting some Trailing Gazania, but if you’re looking for a lower plant, go with the Clumping Gazania.

    Like

  10. The critiques on this item provide testimonials of a number of customers of the solution and it shows how their living has changed considering that then.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s